Mind Wake vs Brain Memory Keeper: Which One Fits You?

Updated 2026-10-08 · NaturaMind Research Editorial Team

Disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. This content is for information only and is not medical advice — talk to your doctor before starting any supplement.

Put the two ingredient lists next to each other and Mind Wake and Brain Memory Keeper look almost like twins. Both are one-a-day capsules built around bacopa, ginkgo, phosphatidylserine, acetyl-L-carnitine, L-glutamine and alpha-GPC. The deciding factor is a single extra herb in Brain Memory Keeper: St. John's wort. Here is how they stack up using only what each official website states.

Side-by-side comparison

Prices are from the order pages at the time of writing; Mind Wake shows a different package mix on another version of its site.

The shared core: what it can and cannot do

Both formulas lean on bacopa for memory support, the ingredient with the most consistent small-trial evidence in healthy adults (2012 systematic review). Ginkgo is the most famous name on both labels, but NCCIH reports that large trials did not find it lowered dementia risk. The choline sources (alpha-GPC, phosphatidylserine) and acetyl-L-carnitine have limited or mixed human data.

Neither brand publishes a trial of its finished product, and neither prints doses on the sales page, so neither can claim a clear edge in strength.

The difference: St. John's wort

St. John's wort is a mood herb that NCCIH flags for serious interactions with many medicines, from antidepressants and birth control pills to warfarin and some heart drugs. It does not add memory evidence of its own. For a healthy adult on no medication, it may simply be an extra. For anyone on prescriptions, it is a reason to choose carefully.

Which one fits which profile

Choose Mind Wake if you: - take any prescription medicine or birth control - want the simplest version of this ingredient stack - prefer a single bottle with free shipping

Brain Memory Keeper may fit if you: - take no medications and your doctor is comfortable with St. John's wort - want the lowest single-bottle price ($69 before shipping) - value the e-book bonuses or the vegetarian, allergen-free claims

Neither is a fit if you: - take blood thinners without medical approval (ginkgo is in both) - are pregnant, nursing or under 18 - are looking for a treatment for a diagnosed memory condition; see a doctor instead

Cost over three months

At the 3-bottle level, both cost $177, so the price will not decide this one. On a single bottle, Brain Memory Keeper totals $78.99 with shipping versus $89 for Mind Wake. On six bottles they are identical at $294.

Practical buying notes

• Subscriptions. One version of the Mind Wake site mentions that some packages may include an optional subscription. Check the checkout page for any repeat-shipment box before you pay.
• Upsells. Brain Memory Keeper shows an extra two-bottle offer during the purchase process. Decide your quantity before you start.
• Refund timing. Both guarantees are 60 days. With bacopa-based formulas usually studied over about 12 weeks, the refund window closes before that point, so plan your check-in at around week 7.
• Allergen needs. Brain Memory Keeper's page explicitly claims dairy-free and soy-free; Mind Wake's lists gluten-free and non-GMO. If allergens matter, ask both for the full label.

Common questions from readers comparing these two

Is one stronger than the other? There is no way to tell from the sales pages, because neither prints doses.

Can I take one with my morning coffee? Neither lists caffeine. Mind Wake's directions say before a meal; Brain Memory Keeper says once a day.

What if I already take St. John's wort separately? Then Brain Memory Keeper would double it up. Choose Mind Wake or talk to your doctor.

What neither product can tell you yet

Both pages leave the same three questions open: the milligram dose of each ingredient, whether the bacopa is a standardized extract, and how the formula was tested for purity. If those details matter to you, ask support for the Supplement Facts panel before choosing. Whichever one answers more clearly is giving you useful information about the company.

Our take

These are near-identical formulas. The ingredient you should think hardest about is St. John's wort, and that question is about your medicines, not about memory.

See Mind Wake on the official site

See Brain Memory Keeper on the official site

For each product in depth, read the Mind Wake review and the Brain Memory Keeper review. Our safety guide covers St. John's wort and ginkgo interactions in more detail.

Sources consulted: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, nccih.nih.gov.